Plano, Texas Jury Awards $6,100 in Rear-End Collision

On November 20, 2012, a process server was driving a Toyota Camry northbound on Preston Road in Plano, Texas, when their vehicle was rear-ended by a Nissan Altima at a traffic light at Park Boulevard. The plaintiff, who claimed neck and back injuries, subsequently filed a lawsuit against the driver of the Nissan, alleging negligence.

The plaintiff reported experiencing cervical disc bulges, lumbar sprains, headaches, and blurry vision following the collision. Treatment included an emergency room visit, chiropractic care, consultations with a neurologist, and epidural steroid injections administered by an orthopedic surgeon. The plaintiff sought approximately $61,000 for medical expenses, along with damages for past pain and suffering and physical impairment. An orthopedic surgeon testified that the plaintiff's treatment was reasonable, necessary, and caused by the accident.

The defendant admitted to rear-ending the plaintiff but argued it was an accident. The defendant stated the traffic light had turned green, and while turning to assist a sick child, they did not realize the plaintiff's vehicle had not moved forward. Defense counsel challenged the extent of the plaintiff's injuries and the necessity of treatment, highlighting a 105-day gap in care and suggesting a financial interest by the treating orthopedic surgeon. The defense also presented evidence of minor vehicle damage and noted the plaintiff had a history of lumbar pain.

After a one-day trial, a jury found the defendant negligent. The jury awarded the plaintiff $6,100, specifically for past medical bills. No damages were awarded for pain and suffering or physical impairment. The limited award suggested the jury accepted some, but not all, of the plaintiff's claimed medical expenses, possibly influenced by the defense's arguments regarding the treatment gap, physician's credibility, and the nature of the impact.