Louisville Jury Awards $39,161 for Medical Bills in Red-Light Crash

A collision occurred at the intersection of St. Matthews Avenue and Shelbyville Road, involving the plaintiff and the defendant. The plaintiff alleged the defendant ran a red light, causing a moderate T-bone impact. Nine days after the incident, the plaintiff sought initial treatment in New Albany for shoulder pain. After an 18-month gap in treatment, the plaintiff returned, and an MRI revealed a labral tear. Surgical repair of the shoulder was performed in September 2023.

The plaintiff filed a lawsuit, asserting the defendant was responsible for the crash. The plaintiff sought $70,992 for medical bills and an additional $250,000 for pain and suffering. The defendant contested liability for the collision and disputed the extent of damages. The defense argued the labral tear, diagnosed 18 months post-incident, was more likely related to the plaintiff's active lifestyle, which included golf, volleyball, and kayaking. An independent medical examination from Louisville was presented. The defendant also raised a defense concerning the threshold of reasonably necessary medical expenses.

The case proceeded to a three-day jury trial. The jury first found for the plaintiff on the threshold question. The jury then determined the defendant was solely at fault for the crash. The plaintiff was awarded $39,161 for medical bills but received no damages for pain and suffering. All findings, except for the threshold question, were unanimous. A judgment of $29,161 was entered for the plaintiff, representing the raw verdict less personal injury protection (PIP) benefits.