Harris County Jury Awards $657 in Rear-End Collision

On November 2, 2015, in Harris County, a fire-alarm installer driving a pickup truck on a freeway feeder road slowed for traffic and was rear-ended by a sport utility vehicle. The plaintiff, who reported back injuries, subsequently sued the SUV driver, alleging negligent vehicle operation. The defendant conceded liability for the collision, and the trial proceeded to determine the extent of damages.

The plaintiff claimed cervical and lumbar sprains and strains, asserting that the trauma resulted in disc bulges and radiculitis. The plaintiff sought over $19,000, which included past medical expenses, lost earning capacity, and damages for physical pain and impairment. The defense disputed the extent of the injuries, citing a 45-day gap in the plaintiff's treatment, the plaintiff's return to work the day after the incident, and photographs showing minimal damage to the plaintiff's truck compared to the defendant's SUV. The defense suggested an award of $332 for initial medical costs and $325 for lost earning capacity.

After one hour of deliberation, the jury awarded the plaintiff $657. This award included $332 for past medical expenses and $325 for past loss of earning capacity. The jury's verdict aligned with the damage amounts proposed by the defense, suggesting the jury was persuaded by arguments that minimized the claimed injuries and the extent of damages.