Fort Worth Jury Finds Negligence in Left Turn Crash, Awards $9,731.50

A collision occurred on November 11, 2015, on Roaring Springs Road in Fort Worth when the defendant, turning left from an apartment complex exit, was struck by the plaintiff's sedan. The plaintiff, who reported neck and back injuries, subsequently filed a lawsuit alleging negligence against the defendant. An initial claim against the vehicle's owner was later dropped.

The plaintiff testified that he saw the defendant stop and did not expect her to pull out. He claimed cervical and lumbar disc protrusions, seeking over $250,000 in damages for past and future medical expenses, pain, and impairment, among other claims. The defendant testified she looked left, did not see the plaintiff, and believed it was safe to proceed, denying distraction. Defense counsel argued the defendant exercised ordinary care, noting that a road curve hindered visibility for both drivers.

A defense expert chiropractor challenged the plaintiff's medical necessity, opining that treatment was excessive and MRIs were unnecessary. The defense also highlighted common ownership among the plaintiff's medical providers and opposed awards for future medical expenses.

The jury found the defendant liable for the accident. However, it awarded the plaintiff $9,731.50, specifically $7,232 for past medical costs and $2,500 for past physical pain and mental anguish. The award was substantially lower than the plaintiff's request, reflecting the jury's acceptance of defense arguments regarding the extent and necessity of the claimed damages.