Verdictly
Verdict-Defense
Dutchess County • 2022

Dutchess County Insurance Subrogation Case Concludes

One vehicle rear-ended another vehicle. The owner of the first vehicle had an insurance policy for collision loss. The insurance company paid the owner for property damage and then filed a lawsuit against the driver of the second vehicle to recover the money paid. The second vehicle's driver denied the allegations and raised several defenses. The parties later agreed to dismiss the case.

Case Information Updated: October 2025

Back to cases
Other Injury
Rear-end
Motor Vehicle Negligence

Case Outcome

Outcome
Verdict-Defense
Amount
$17,356
County
Dutchess County, NY
Resolved
2022

Injury & Accident Details

Injury Type
Other
Accident Type
Rear-end
Case Type
Motor Vehicle Negligence

Settlement Context

This verdict-defense of $17,356 is above the median of Undisclosed for other cases resolved by verdict-defense. The typical range is Undisclosed to $9,827, based on 107 cases in our database.

Case Overview

An insurance company initiated a subrogation action in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Ninth Judicial District, Dutchess County, following a collision between a 2012 Kia and a 2016 Hyundai. The insurer, as subrogee of its insured, sought to recover $17,356.24 for property damage and additional personal injury protection damages paid as a result of the incident.

The insurer contended that the collision occurred due to the negligence of the Kia's owner and operator. The defendants, the Kia's owner and operator, denied the allegations and asserted several affirmative defenses, including assumption of risk, culpable conduct, and contributory negligence. The parties later filed a stipulation of discontinuance with prejudice, concluding the case.

Understanding This Case

  • This case went to trial and resulted in a jury verdict. Verdicts can yield higher awards but carry the risk of receiving nothing if the jury rules against the plaintiff.
  • This case was resolved in Dutchess County, New York. Local jury tendencies, judge assignments, and regional economic conditions all influence case outcomes in this jurisdiction.
  • Resolved in 2022, this case reflects the legal and economic conditions of that period, including medical costs, insurance practices, and jury award trends at the time.

VerdictlyTM Score

65
/100
Reasonably Fair

This outcome is within expected ranges

This score is calculated by analyzing injury type, accident details, geographic location, temporal trends, and comparing against 2,000+ similar cases in our database.

Curious about your case value?

Get a free case evaluation to understand what your motor vehicle accident case might be worth based on cases like this in Dutchess County.

Check Your Case Value

Similar cases you may find useful

Handpicked by matching injury type, accident details, and outcome to this case.

Undisclosed
Verdict-Defense
Other Injury
Rear-end

A civil lawsuit stemmed from a rear-end collision in Denver, Colorado. The defendant presented expert testimony from an individual specializing in orthopedic surgery. Specific details regarding the incident, the plaintiff's claims, or the ultimate resolution of the case were not available in the record.

Denver County • 2022
View full case
Undisclosed
Verdict-Defense
Other Injury
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

The employer, Star*Tel Systems, appealed a decision by an administrative law judge in Kentucky. The judge had previously determined that an employee sustained a permanent and total disability following a work-related motor vehicle accident. The appeal challenged the judge's opinion, order, and award.

Dallas County • 2015
View full case
Undisclosed
Verdict-Defense
Other Injury
Pedestrian
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A lawsuit stemmed from a motor vehicle and pedestrian collision. The plaintiff presented expert testimony related to life care planning and rehabilitation, indicating claims for long-term care and disability. The defendant countered with expert testimony from fields including psychology, neuropsychology, and orthopedic surgery. The parties reached a resolution, and the case was concluded with a stipulated dismissal in April 2019.

Dallas County • 2019
View full case
Undisclosed
Verdict-Defense
Other Injury
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A personal injury case arose from an auto accident. The plaintiff retained an expert in economics to assess damages. The defendant presented experts in emergency medicine, biomechanics, and accident reconstruction, suggesting disputes over the nature or cause of injuries. An occupational therapy expert also participated in the case. The matter proceeded to a trial, which concluded on December 9, 2016. Details regarding the verdict or any award were not specified in the record.

Larimer County • 2016
View full case
Undisclosed
Settlement
Other Injury
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A motor vehicle collision occurred in Mesa County, Colorado, involving a vehicle operated by the defendant and another car carrying the plaintiff as a passenger. The plaintiff alleged the incident caused permanent personal injuries, pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and resulted in medical expenses and economic losses. The plaintiff filed a vehicular liability action in the Colorado District Court, Twenty-First Judicial District, County of Mesa, claiming the defendant's negligence. Allegations included failing to operate the vehicle prudently, maintain a proper lookout, obey traffic control devices, driving at an excessive speed, and failing to stop at a red light. The plaintiff sought damages for the alleged harm. In response, the defendant denied the allegations of negligence. The defendant also asserted affirmative defenses, including claims of failure to state a claim, culpable conduct, and failure to mitigate damages. The parties subsequently filed a notice with the court indicating that they had reached a settlement in the action.

Mesa County • 2017
View full case