Casselberry Jury Awards $6,699 in Rear-End Collision

On April 10, 1997, a collision occurred at 5:30 p.m. in Casselberry, Florida, at the intersection of SR 436 and Lake Howell Lane. A plaintiff was stopped at a traffic light when a defendant's minivan, whose driver assumed traffic was moving, idled forward and struck the rear of the plaintiff's vehicle. The plaintiff's vehicle sustained approximately $293 in property damage.

The plaintiff filed a lawsuit seeking recovery for medical bills, past lost wages, and pain and suffering. The defendant admitted fault for the accident itself but disputed that the collision caused any of the plaintiff's claimed injuries. Both sides presented expert medical testimony, with the plaintiff offering chiropractic and orthopedic specialists, and the defendant presenting an orthopedic expert.

During closing arguments, plaintiff's counsel contended that the incident significantly altered the plaintiff's life, entitling compensation for past and future pain and suffering and future medical expenses. Defense counsel countered by highlighting the plaintiff's continued engagement in activities, including working out and swimming three times a week post-accident, suggesting no substantial impact on daily life.

The jury found that the plaintiff sustained a permanent injury as a result of the collision. However, the jury did not award any damages for future medical bills or future pain and suffering. Following an offset for personal injury protection (PIP) benefits previously paid, a net judgment of $6,699 was recorded.