What to Expect at a Free Personal Injury Consultation
A free consultation with a personal injury attorney is one of the most important steps you can take after an accident. It costs you nothing, carries no obligation, and can help you understand whether you have a viable claim. Knowing what to expect beforehand allows you to make the most of that meeting and ask the right questions.
What to Bring to Your Free Consultation
Walking into your consultation prepared makes a significant difference. The more information your attorney has upfront, the more accurate their case evaluation will be. Gather these documents before your appointment.
Police Report
The official accident report filed by law enforcement at the scene. This document records the date, time, location, involved parties, and the officer's initial determination of fault. If you haven't obtained a copy yet, your attorney can help you request one, but bringing it to the consultation saves valuable time.
Medical Records & Bills
Gather all medical documentation related to your injury, including emergency room records, diagnostic imaging results, treatment plans, prescription records, and itemized bills. These documents establish the severity of your injury and the cost of treatment, both of which directly influence the value of your claim.
Photos & Evidence
Bring any photos or videos from the accident scene, including vehicle damage, road conditions, traffic signals, and visible injuries. If you took screenshots of text messages, social media posts, or dashcam footage related to the incident, include those as well. Visual evidence strengthens your case significantly.
Insurance Information
Have your own auto insurance policy details available, along with any information you have about the other driver's insurance. If you've already been contacted by an insurance adjuster, bring notes about those conversations, including any settlement offers they may have made. Never accept an offer before consulting an attorney.
Personal Notes & Timeline
Write down your account of the accident while it's fresh, including a timeline of events leading up to, during, and after the collision. Note any witnesses and their contact information, lost wages, missed appointments, and how the injury has affected your daily routine. A detailed personal account helps the attorney build a complete picture.
What Happens During the Consultation
Understanding the structure of a typical free personal injury consultation helps you feel confident and prepared. Here is the general flow of the meeting, whether it takes place in person, over the phone, or by video call.
The Attorney Reviews Your Case Facts
The consultation typically begins with the attorney asking you to describe what happened. They will review the documents you've brought, ask about the circumstances of the accident, and listen to your account without interruption. A thorough attorney will want to understand the full picture before offering any assessment.
They Ask Clarifying Questions
Expect detailed follow-up questions about liability, the extent of your injuries, your medical treatment to date, and any interactions you've had with insurance companies. The attorney may also ask about pre-existing conditions, as insurance companies frequently use those to reduce your claim. Honest answers, even about sensitive details, help the attorney evaluate your case accurately.
Case Strength Evaluation
Based on the facts, the attorney will give you a candid assessment of your case strength. They will explain whether liability is clear or contested, whether your damages support a viable claim, and what challenges you might face. A reputable attorney will be straightforward, even if the news isn't what you hoped to hear.
Discussion of Legal Options
The attorney will explain your options moving forward. This may include filing an insurance claim, negotiating a settlement, or pursuing litigation. They will outline the general process, expected timeline, and how their fee structure works, which in personal injury cases is almost always a contingency fee. This means you pay nothing upfront and the attorney only gets paid if you win.
Questions You Should Ask During Your Consultation
A free consultation is a two-way conversation. While the attorney evaluates your case, you should be evaluating the attorney. These are the key questions that will help you determine whether they are the right fit for your case.
How much experience do you have with cases like mine?
Ask specifically about personal injury cases involving your type of accident and injury. An attorney who regularly handles car accident cases in Texas courts will understand local procedures, judges, and insurance company tactics far better than a generalist. Ask how many similar cases they've resolved and what outcomes they achieved.
What is your fee structure?
Most personal injury attorneys work on contingency, typically charging 33% of your settlement before litigation or 40% if the case goes to trial. Make sure you understand exactly what percentage they charge, whether costs and expenses are deducted before or after the fee, and what happens if your case doesn't result in a recovery. There should be no hidden fees.
What is the expected timeline for my case?
Personal injury cases in Texas can take anywhere from a few months to several years depending on complexity. Ask the attorney for a realistic timeline based on your specific facts. Cases involving clear liability and documented injuries typically settle faster, while disputed liability or catastrophic injuries may require extended litigation.
How will we communicate throughout the process?
Understand how often you'll receive updates and through what channels, whether phone, email, or a client portal. Ask who your primary point of contact will be, whether it will be the attorney directly or a paralegal. Consistent communication is one of the most important factors in a successful attorney-client relationship.
What results have you achieved in similar cases?
While past results never guarantee future outcomes, understanding an attorney's track record gives you a sense of their capability. Ask about average settlement amounts for cases similar to yours, their trial experience, and their success rate. An experienced attorney will be comfortable discussing their record transparently.
Red Flags to Watch For
Not every attorney who offers a free consultation has your best interests in mind. Watch for these warning signs during your meeting and trust your instincts if something feels off.
Pressure to Sign a Retainer Immediately
A reputable personal injury attorney will never pressure you into signing a retainer agreement on the spot. The free consultation is your opportunity to evaluate the attorney, just as they are evaluating your case. If you feel rushed or pressured to commit before you've had time to think, consider it a warning sign. You should always feel comfortable taking a day or two to make your decision.
Guaranteed Outcomes or Specific Dollar Amounts
No attorney can guarantee a specific settlement amount or a particular outcome. Every case depends on unique facts, evidence quality, insurance coverage limits, and many variables outside anyone's control. If an attorney tells you your case is worth a specific dollar figure during an initial consultation, or promises you'll definitely win, they're being dishonest. Ethical attorneys provide ranges based on experience and data, not guarantees.
Unclear or Evasive Fee Terms
Contingency fee arrangements should be straightforward and easy to understand. If an attorney cannot clearly explain their percentage, how expenses are handled, or what costs you might be responsible for if the case is unsuccessful, that's a red flag. Legitimate attorneys put everything in writing and welcome questions about their fee structure.
No Meaningful Case Evaluation
A free consultation that feels more like a sales pitch than a legal evaluation is a problem. If the attorney spends the entire meeting talking about how great their firm is without asking detailed questions about your accident, reviewing your documents, or providing a candid assessment of your case, they may be more interested in signing clients than achieving results. A good consultation involves genuine two-way dialogue.
After the Consultation: What Happens Next
Once the free consultation is over, you have several options. There is no obligation to proceed, and taking time to consider your choices is always appropriate.
Take Time to Decide
You do not need to make a decision during or immediately after the consultation. Take a day or two to reflect on the attorney's assessment, their communication style, and whether you felt comfortable and heard. If you're consulting with multiple attorneys, compare their evaluations and fee structures before committing.
Understand the Timeline
If you decide to hire an attorney, the next steps typically include signing a retainer agreement, authorizing the attorney to obtain your medical records, and beginning the investigation phase. In Texas, the statute of limitations for most personal injury claims is two years from the date of the accident, so while you should not rush your decision, you also should not delay indefinitely.
The Retainer Agreement
A retainer agreement is the contract between you and your attorney. Read it carefully before signing. It should clearly state the contingency fee percentage, how case expenses are handled, the scope of the attorney's representation, and the process for ending the relationship if needed. A trustworthy attorney will walk you through every section and answer any questions you have about the terms.
Frequently Asked Questions About Free Consultations
Common questions people have before scheduling a free personal injury consultation.
Do I have to pay anything for a free personal injury consultation?
How long does a free personal injury consultation typically last?
Can I consult with more than one attorney before deciding?
What if the attorney says I don't have a case?
Should I talk to insurance companies before my consultation?
Can I do a free consultation by phone or video call?
What happens if I decide to hire the attorney after the consultation?
Related Resources
Ready to Take the Next Step?
Use our tools to estimate your settlement value or find an experienced personal injury attorney in Texas who offers free consultations.