Texas Jury Awards $2,700 in Hurst Rear-End Collision

In November 2013, in Hurst, Texas, a sedan driven by the plaintiff was rear-ended by a sport utility vehicle operated by the defendant driver. The plaintiff had stopped at a red light and was momentarily distracted by a cell phone when the light turned green, causing her to delay proceeding. The defendant driver then released the brake, believing the plaintiff would move forward, resulting in the collision.

The plaintiff alleged the defendant driver was negligent and claimed neck and back injuries, including cervical and lumbar sprains and strains. She sought approximately $14,700 for medical costs, $384 for lost wages, and damages for physical pain. Her treatment included emergency room visits, chiropractic care, an MRI showing a lumbar disc bulge, and a consultation with an orthopedic surgeon.

The defense argued the defendant driver's actions did not constitute negligence, asserting he merely anticipated the plaintiff's movement. The defense also contested the extent and necessity of the plaintiff's claimed injuries and medical treatment. They presented post-accident photos showing no visible damage to the plaintiff's vehicle, highlighted her lack of primary care physician treatment, and noted a prior accident involving lower back issues. A defense expert in physical medicine and rehabilitation provided an affidavit estimating reasonable and necessary medical costs at $2,713.80.

Following the trial, the jury found the defendant driver negligent. However, the jury awarded the plaintiff $2,700 for past medical bills only. The award amount closely aligned with the defense expert's valuation, indicating the jury largely accepted the defense's arguments regarding the reasonableness and necessity of the plaintiff's medical expenses.